Hello there, JImOhio. 

Cleared bank transactions don't mean they're already reconciled in QuickBooks. You'll have to reconcile them so they won't show up every time you reconcile. You can do a "mini-reconciliation" for these past cleared transactions. 

However, if they're already reconciled and shows up as cleared or unreconciled, it's possible that you've accidentally edited these transactions after reconciliation or data damage caused them to show up. We can run verify and rebuild data to fix this. 

You can refer to this article for more information about reconciling bank and credit card accounts. 

I'm here to assist you with your concerns. Have a good one!