2019-01-30 22:43:18Accounting & TaxesEnglishTo implement GST effectively, penalties under GST Penalty have been levied to prevent evasion of tax and to punish those who breach the law.https://quickbooks.intuit.com/in/resources/in_qrc/uploads/2019/01/brown-gavel-on-a-white-tax-law-document-picture-id155392441.jpghttps://quickbooks.intuit.com/in/resources/accounting-taxes/gst-penalty-a-guide-to-gst-offences-penalties-and-appeals/GST Penalty: A Guide to GST Offences, Penalties and Appeals

GST Penalty: A Guide to GST Offences, Penalties and Appeals

12 min read

Introduction of Goods and Services Tax (GST) is not merely a tax reform. It’s a complete overhaul of the pre-existing indirect tax regime. This is because it makes way for a simpler indirect tax system and an enhanced compliance. Simplicity in GST regime stems from integration of a host of indirect taxes levied previously. And the enhanced compliance results from digitization brought about in implementing GST. Digitization involves shifting each aspect of procedural compliance online. Each aspect of compliance has been duly automated including application for registration, return filing, or refund processing. 

And, to further aid effective implementation of the GST system, penal provisions for law offenders have been laid down. These penalties under GST Penalty are levied to prevent evasion of tax and to punish those who breach the law.

Types of Offences

Like the pre-existing indirect taxes, offences under GST system are divided into 2 categories:

  1. Offences Attracting Fiscal Penalties
  2. Offences Attracting Prosecution    

The offences drawing fiscal penalties involve proceedings that are quasi-judicial in nature. Such proceedings are carried out by the departmental officers.  Offences attracting prosecution, on the other hand, are judicial in nature. Such proceedings are dealt by Courts and may lead to imprisonment or fine.

Furthermore, the offences attracting fiscal penalty can be further bifurcated into Revenue Issues and Procedural Issues. Revenue issues involve demand and recovery of amount of tax, interest, penalty or fine due to government. The procedural issues, on the other hand, include contravention of prescribed procedures or modalities not involving revenue.

Hence, to help you understand the penalties attached with various offences, here is a complete guide on GST Penalty.

And, to further aid effective implementation of the GST system, penal provisions for law offenders have been laid down. These penalties are levied to prevent evasion of tax and to punish those who breach the law.

Guide to GST Offences and Penalties

This guide will talk about:

  1. Penalty for Certain Offences
  2. Fines for Failure to Furnish Information Return (IR)
  3. Penalty for Failure to Furnish Statistics
  4. General Penalty
  5. Punishment for Certain Offences

I. Penalty for Certain Offences

Section 122 of the CGST Act, 2017, lays down certain offences along with the fiscal penalties. This section is divided into 3 sub-sections, each attracting different penalties.

1. Offences and Penalties Under Sub-Section 1

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(i), 122 (1)(ii) and 122 (1)(xix) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person you:

  1. Make supply of goods or services
    1. without issuing invoice
    2. issuing incorrect or false invoice
  2. Issue invoice or bill of supply without making a supply in violation of the provisions of the Act or Rules.
  3. Furnish invoice or document using the registration number of another registered person.

II. Offences Involving Fraud

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(viii), 122 (1)(x) and 122 (1)(xii) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person you:

  1. Obtain refund of tax fraudulently
  2. With an intention to evade payment of tax:
    1. Falsify or substitute financial records
    2. Produce fake accounts or documents
    3. Furnish any false information or return
  3. Furnish false information with regards to registration particulars either:
    1. At the time of applying for registration or
    2. Subsequently

III. Offences Related With Tax Evasion

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(iii), 122 (1)(iv) and 122 (1)(xv) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person, you:

  1. Collect tax but fail to deposit it to the government. Provided such a tax is not deposited for a period exceeding 3 months from due date.
  2. Suppress your turnover leading to evasion of tax.
  3. Collect tax in contravention of law but fail to deposit it to the government. Provided such a tax is not deposited for a period exceeding 3 months from due date.

IV. Offences Related With TDS and TCS

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(v) and 122 (1)(vi) respectively. Accordingly, such offences originate if as a taxable person, you:

  1. Fail to:
    1. Deduct tax or deduct appropriate tax as per section 51. Section 51 is applicable for certain specific persons. It requires such persons to deduct tax at the rate of 1 per cent out of the payment to the supplier. Provided the value of supply under the contract exceeds Rs 2.50 Lakhs.
    2. Deposit the deducted tax to the government
  2. Fail to:
    1. Collect tax or collect appropriate tax as per section 52. Section 52 is applicable for electronic commerce operators. Such operators are required to collect tax from the supplier at the time of payment. The tax collected should be at the rate of 1 per cent.
    2. Deposit the collected tax to the government

V. Offences Related With Input Tax Credit (ITC)

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(vii) and 122 (1)(ix) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person, you:

  1. Utilize ITC without actual receipt of supply either fully or partially
  2. Distribute ITC in contravention of section 20 or rules there under

VI. Offences On Account of Failures

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(xi), 122 (1)(xvi) and 122 (1)(xvii) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person, you:

  1. Are liable to be registered but fail to obtain registration
  2. Fail to keep, maintain or retain books of accounts and other documents in the manner prescribed
  3. Either fail to furnish information or documents called for by an officer. Or furnish false information or documents during any proceedings.

VII. Offences Related With Transportation And Storage

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(xiv) and 122 (1)(xviii) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person, you:

  1. Transport any taxable goods without the cover of specified documents
  2. Supply, transport or store any goods which you believe are liable to confiscation

VIII. Miscellaneous Offences

Following offences relate to section 122 (1)(xiii), 122 (1)(xx) and 122 (xxi) respectively. Accordingly, such offences occur if as a taxable person, you:

  1. Obstruct or prevent any officer in discharge of his duties
  2. Tamper with or destroy any material document
  3. Dispose off or tamper with any goods that have been detained, seized or attached under the Act

Penalty Levied: If you as an offender commit any of the above offences, you shall be liable to pay a sum which is higher out of:

  • a penalty of Rs 10,000 or
  • an amount equal to the amount of tax evaded

2. Offences and Penalties Under Sub-Section 2

Following offence relates to section 122 (2). These provisions refer to you as a registered person if you supply goods or services on which:

  • Any tax has not been paid
  • Tax has been short-paid
  • Any tax has been erroneously refunded
  • ITC has been wrongly availed or utilized

Hence, if you are such a supplier who makes a supply for any of the following two reasons, the penalties attached would be levied.

Reasons For Supply

  • Firstly, for reasons other than fraud, willful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. In such a case, you as an offender shall be liable to pay a penalty which is higher of:
    • A sum equal to Rs 10,000 or
    • 10 percent of the tax due from such a person
  • Secondly, for any reason of fraud or willful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. In such a case, you as an offender shall be liable to pay a penalty which is higher of:
    • A sum equal to Rs 10,000 or
    • 100% of the tax due from such a person

3. Offences and Penalties Under Sub-Section 3

Following offences relate to section 122 (3). These offences deal with the situations where you are not directly involved in tax evasion. Instead, you aid or abet or may be a party to such an evasion. Furthermore, it also includes cases where you do not attend summons or produce documents.

Accordingly, those cases are as follows:

  1. Aiding or abetting any of the offences specified in clauses (i) to (xxi) of sub-section (1)
  2. Acquiring or concerning with goods which are liable to confiscation. It includes transporting, removing, depositing, keeping, concealing, supplying, purchasing or other ways of dealing with goods.
  3. Failing to issue an invoice in accordance with the provisions of the Act or Rules. Or failing to account for an invoice in books of accounts.
  4. Receiving or concerning with the supply of services which are in contravention of the provision of the Act or Rules. It also includes any other manner of dealing with such a supply of services.
  5. Failing to appear before the officer of the Central Tax. Provided you are issued with summon for appearance in an inquiry. And you are supposed to give evidence or produce any document in such an inquiry.

Penalty: If you as an offender commit any of the above offences, then you shall be liable to pay a penalty which may extend to Rs 25,000.

II. Penalty for Failure to Furnish Information Return (IR)

Under the CGST Act, 2017, section 123 deals with circumstances where you fail to file an Information Return under section 150.

Section 150 lays down cases where you are obligated to furnish an Information Return. If you fail to furnish an Information Return in such cases within a stipulated period, it calls for a penalty. The stipulated period to file Information Return is 30 days from the date of issue of show cause notice.

Penalty: If you fail to file IR within stipulated time, you shall be liable to a penalty of Rs 100 each day for which the failure continues. Such a penalty cannot exceed Rs 5,000.

III. Penalty for Failure to Furnish Statistics

Section 124 of the CGST Act, 2017, deals with penalty levied in circumstances where you fail to furnish information under section 151.

According to section 151, a Commissioner has the power to collect statistics concerning any matter dealt with under the Act.  He may issue a notice asking you to furnish information or returns in a prescribed format. Such information relates to the matters for which statistics are to be collected.

Therefore, section 124 specifies penalty for failure to provide information or return in two circumstances:

  • Failing to furnish such information or return without reasonable cause
  • Willfully furnishing or causing to furnish any information or return which is known to be false

Penalty: If you fail to furnish such information, you shall be liable to a fine of up to Rs 10,000. But where the offence is continuing, a further fine of Rs 100 is levied each day for which the failure continues. However, such a penalty cannot exceed Rs 25,000.

IV. General Penalty

Section 125 of the CGST Act, 2017, deals with such cases where no separate penalty is prescribed under the Act or Rules. Accordingly, it refers to cases where you contravene

  • Any of the provisions of the Act or
  • Rules made there under

Provided, there is no penalty separately prescribed for such an offence under the Act.

Penalty: The penalty imposable in such a case is up to Rs 25,000.

V. Punishment for Certain Offences

Section 132 of the CGST Act, 2017 describes cases of tax evasion and the penal actions applicable on specific events. This section provides for cases where your offences lead to prosecution and accordingly a punishment is initiated on you. The term prosecution means conducting legal proceedings against an offender before a legal tribunal. And the punishment for such an offence involves either imprisonment or fine or both.

A. This part enumerates cases identified by law makers as offences liable for prosecution:

  1. Supplying goods or services or both without the cover of invoice. Provided it is done with the intention of evading tax.
  2. Issuing any invoice or bill without actual supply of goods or services or both. Provided such an act leads to wrongful input tax credit or refund of tax.
  3. Availing ITC using invoice referred to in point (ii) above.
  4. Collecting taxes without any payment to the government for a period exceeding 3 months from due date.
  5. Evading tax, availing credit or obtaining refund with the intent of fraud. Where such offence is not covered in clause (i) to (iv) above.
  6. Falsifying financial records or producing false records/ accounts/ documents/ information. Provided it is done with the intention of evading tax.
  7. Obstructing or preventing any officer from doing his duties under the act.
  8. Acquiring or transporting or in any manner dealing with goods liable for confiscation under this Act.
  9. Receiving or dealing with supply of services which are in contravention of any provisions of this law.
  10. Tampering or destroying any material evidence or documents.
  11. Failing to supply information which a person is required to supply under this law. Or supplying false information.
  12. Attempting or abetting the commission of any of the offences mentioned above.

Now, this section enables commencement of prosecution proceedings against the offenders. It also lists the period of imprisonment and quantum of fine for all such prosecution offences. Such a punishment varies depending on the amount of tax evaded or seriousness of the offence as listed below.

A guide to GST penalty, offences and appeals

B. This part deals with persons committing any offence specified in clause (vi), (vii) or (x) above. Such offenders shall be punishable with:

  • imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months or
  • fine or
  • both

C. This part deals with repetitive offences.

There are cases where you are convicted of repetitive offences. And such offences without any specific/special reason are to be recorded in the judgment of the Court. Such offences will entail an imprisonment term of not less than 6 months. But such imprisonment could extend to 5 years plus a fine.

D. All offences mentioned in this section are non-cognizable and bailable except the following cases:

(i) Where the amount exceeds 5 Crores and
(ii) Instances covered by (a) to (d) in Para A.

E. Every prosecution proceeding initiated under this section requires prior sanction of the Commissioner.

Information may be abridged and therefore incomplete. This document/information does not constitute, and should not be considered a substitute for, legal or financial advice. Each financial situation is different, the advice provided is intended to be general. Please contact your financial or legal advisors for information specific to your situation.

Related Articles

Interest and Penalty under GST

Interest and Penalty under GST Government implemented the massive tax reform in…

Read more

Goods And Services Tax: What Is GST In India?

Background Goods and Services Tax (GST) is one of the greatest indirect…

Read more

A Quick Tour of the GST Portal and Enrolment

Goods and Service Tax (GST) is one of the biggest tax reforms…

Read more