When former journalist Kari Browne had her children she knew that the travelling lifestyle of a news producer would be difficult, she decided to open a kid-friendly cafe in her Brooklyn, New York neighbourhood. She built it from the ground up and managed it herself. She bought a second cafe 2 years later, also styling it into a hip, kid-friendly venue.
In 2016 her family followed an opportunity to Australia, and Kari sold both of her cafes. We spoke with Kari about the process of valuing her business, finding the “right” buyer and leaving behind something she built with love.
When it came time to sell your business, where did you start?
When we decided to move to Sydney, I was told the only way to sell my cafes was to use a business broker. I contacted a couple of brokers who wanted steep fees and knew nothing about my businesses. They told me to sell them as a generic business and get an investor to buy them who may turn them into other businesses. Essentially, they would be valuing my business based on the terms of only my lease. That whole process sounded so thoughtless, so transactional and not personal at all - everything my cafes were not.
What did you want from the sale of your cafes?
I decided to take a huge risk and list the cafes myself by making an announcement on social media and by giving an interview to our neighbourhood’s local blog. I was able to control the narrative of the sale and explain why I was selling - that the cafes were thriving, not failing - and what I hoped for my businesses. Ideally, I hoped someone else in the community would buy them and continue running them.
From the moment the word got out, I was flooded with emails and interest. I had specifically targeted neighbours and customers who, perhaps, had always wanted to own and run a cafe like mine. I knew other people shared my dream.
I pitched it in terms of having already done a lot of the hard work of opening a new business. I’d found staff, gained a following, developed relationships with vendors and so on. All a new owner had to do was maintain what was there and continue to grow. That’s still a huge task - maintaining and growing a business is just as difficult as starting them from the ground up.
What was interest from buyers like?
I was selling the cafes “as is”, with staff, vendors, menus, equipment, a website and customers included. I met with dozens of interested buyers. The main themes that emerged were being burnt out in their job, wanting to pursue a long-held dream of owning a cafe or they were ready for something creative and local. And everyone loved the idea of working for themselves.
Who was the “right” buyer?
Selfishly, I wanted the legacy of these cafes to continue. I also wanted to find someone who would not just take over the businesses but grow them while being realistic about how difficult it can be. Entrepreneurship is not for everyone - it’s one of the toughest things I’ve ever done in my life. But it’s also one of the most rewarding adventures I’ve ever been on.
A married couple approached me, both with Wall Street backgrounds who lived in the neighbourhood. They were really excited about the prospect of taking over both cafes, which was appealing because the integrity of each one would stay the same.
We had long and candid conversations about business ownership - the challenges, the slow times, absent employees. They asked all the right questions, and I felt like they were up for the challenge. They really connected with the vision of the cafes, and they wanted everything to stay the same. They didn’t even want to close for a day. It was important for them to keep the continuity. I loved that.
What happened when it came time to sell?
It was super emotional. But I loved meeting with prospective buyers. It was therapeutic for me to talk openly about selling and trying to find the best match between the businesses and the new owners. So many customers and neighbours praised what we had built in our community, and seeing how many people wanted to take over and continue the legacy was the most incredible feeling.
How did you value your businesses?
The figure was a difficult one to arrive at. The previously mentioned brokers would have used a valuation solely based on the lease, the equipment, furniture and any fixtures we were selling. So I ended up valuing it myself, also including elements I thought had great worth, like the staff, customers, vendors, reputation, marketing materials, social media following, websites and a host of good will.
Those are the things that make valuing a business difficult. The brokers said we wouldn’t get more than $50,000 to $60,000, but we walked away with about 10 times that much! We ended up listing one at $325,000 and the other at $299,000 and they sold for a bit less than that. At the end of the day, your business is worth whatever someone is willing to pay for it.
Were you able to pay back your investors and loans?
Yes, happily I was, and I was so grateful to them for being on the journey with me. Ideally, when determining the selling price, you want to be able to cover all your debts and walk away with something, too.
Do you miss running the cafes?
I really miss the customers and my staff. I miss that feeling of going into the cafes and knowing, “I made this! This is mine!” There’s something really fulfilling about creating something and seeing it flourish.
What are you doing in Australia?
It has obviously been a huge move, and my number-1 priority is settling my family into this new, magical country. This past year, stepping away from the cafes, I’ve had a lot more time with my children. With the cafes, I was on 24/7. I was glued to my phones. That’s the reality of running a small business in the hospitality industry. I’m so glad to have had this past year to devote all the time to my children, to myself, to my family. No one is trying to get in touch with me, and it’s wonderful!