I know how important that employees are being taxed correctly, tjsprankle-yahoo.
Let's verify the employee's payroll information to ensure they're being set correctly. You can also delete and recreate then.
If you get the same result after performing the workaround above, I recommend contacting our Payroll Support Team. They can review your account in a secure environment and check further details on our back end. For more info, feel free to open this reference for your guide: Contact Payroll Support.
In addition, here's a reference that you can read to help manage your payroll transactions in QuickBooks: Run payroll reports.
Let me know how it goes, I want to make sure this is taken care of. Thanks for dropping by, I'll be standing by for your response.