Thank you for posting here in the Community, @Kyle57.
I'd be glad to assist you in opening the IIF file.
This error will usually occur when the file association of the .iif file is changed to other applications other than MS Excel. You'll want to verify the type of file you are opening by right-clicking the file and choosing Properties. The file type is listed under Type of File.
If needed, you'll want to change the file association of the .iif file to open with MS Excel. This way, you'll be able to open the file.
You might want to read this article to learn how to import IIF files in QuickBooks Desktop: Export, import, and edit IIF files.
Please know you can continue to reach me here with any additional questions. Thanks for coming to the Community, wishing you continued success.