Hi there, @SpartanOffroad,
I appreciate you following the steps to resolve the transactions appearing back as unreconciled in your register.
This can happen when previously reconciled transactions have been modified, deleted, or added in the register.
You need to open the Reconciliation Discrepancy report so you can see transactions that were changed since the last reconciliation.
Here's how to pull up the report:
You can also go through this article for additional information: Fix Reconciliation Discrepancies.
Please stay in touch with me on what the results are. I'm here anytime you need help.