Hello there, hyltonhundtsalo.
I appreciate you for joining this thread. I want this reconciliation issue to be taken care of.
Running the Verify and Rebuild tool helps to isolate and fix the issue with reconciliation.
However, if this doesn't work, you'll need to get in touch with our QuickBooks Care Team so they can take a closer look and conduct a deeper investigation about this reconciliation issue.
You can reach them through the contact details found in this link: Contact the QuickBooks Desktop Customer Support Team.
Keep me posted and don't hesitate to get back to me if there's anything else I can hep you with.