Hi there, @tlshuey.
Welcome to the Community. Having your FUTA tax liability to be corrected is my priority so let's get this taken care of.
You can create a negative liability adjustment to offset the Federal Unemployment tax liability.
To know more about the process, please check out this article: Adjust payroll liabilities.
This information should help you get back on track. Feel free to reach back out to me if I can be of additional assistance. I'll make sure to get back to you as soon as I can. Enjoy your weekend!