I'm here to help you fix the payroll taxes in your book, dgrossman.
Getting the latest payroll tax table update will help you sort things out. It is recommended to update it every after 45 days. To do it, you can follow the steps below:
I've added a sample screenshot for additional reference:
Once done, you can go to this link. It routes you to the information on how to double-check if the tax table update was successfully downloaded or installed in your QuickBooks Desktop. If you created a paycheck, you can revert the paycheck and recreate it.
Just let me know if you have other questions by adding a comment below. I'm always here ready to help you out in case you need one. Take care!