Hi there, @lstreicher.
I appreciate following the steps provided above. Since you've tried the suggested solution and work-around. I recommend contacting our Customer Support Team,
as they have the tools to pull up your account in a secure environment.
Take a look at this article to know more about the calculation of taxes and understand the tax amounts reported on your paycheck or the year-to-date (YTD) payroll report: How QuickBooks calculates payroll taxes.
Please don't hesitate to let me know if you should have any questions about this or anything else QuickBooks related. Have a wonderful day!