Thanks for keeping me updated about the steps that you've tried, @neyerbj.
We can try to toggle one of your transactions to refresh the reminder on your QuickBooks.
If doing this doesn't make a difference, I recommend verifying and rebuilding your data. It can help fix data-related issues.
To do that:
For complete details about resolving data issues on the program, please see this link: Fix data damage on your QuickBooks Desktop company file
I'll be around to help if there's anything else you need. Happy Monday!