Greetings, Bdonahue. Thank you for returning to the conversation and providing more information about your bank and PayPal transactions within QuickBooks Online (QBO). I'll share some details to help you clear things up.
If your PayPal account is linked in QBO, you'll have to manually add the transactions by selecting its button in the For Review tab before you can proceed to match them within the system.
Please note that for transactions older than six months, you'll need to use the Find Match button as QuickBooks will no longer automatically suggest matching records within QBO. Refer to the instructions from my colleagues above for guidance on this matter.
Visit these articles for your reference in managing your bank transactions moving forward:
I'll promptly follow up if you require further clarification. The Community is accessible round the clock for any assistance you may need. Have a good one.
