How to Choose New Accounting Clients: A Checklist for Accounting Firms

The initial consultation sets the tone for the entire client relationship. It's where you meet the client, get a feel for how you'll work together, and agree on the terms of engagement. So, it pays to have a consistent process for vetting potential clients before you even get there. 

A clear checklist, built into how you manage client accounting from the start, can save your firm time and headaches down the line. The checklist below covers what to look for before you say yes.

Client evaluation checklist 

Not every potential client is a good fit for your firm, and that's fine. Before you take one on, it helps to run through a short mental checklist covering how they work, what they need, and whether your firm's client accounting services are the right match.

Do they clearly understand their accounting needs?

A client who can't articulate what they need from you, whether that's bookkeeping, tax filing, payroll or advisory work, often doesn't know what a good working relationship looks like either. Ask direct questions about their current pain points and what they're hoping to get out of working with your firm. Vague answers early on are usually a sign of vague expectations later.

Are their expectations realistic?

Every client wants fast turnaround, low fees and deep expertise, but few firms can offer all three at once. Listen for whether a potential client's expectations around pricing, response times and scope of work line up with what your firm can actually deliver. A client who pushes back hard on reasonable boundaries during the sales conversation will likely do the same once they're onboard.

Will they be easy to work with?

Pay attention to how a potential client communicates during the first meeting, not just what they say. Are they responsive, organised and willing to listen, or do they interrupt, dismiss your questions or seem impatient with the process? The way someone behaves in a sales conversation is usually the best preview of how they'll behave as a client.

Are they financially reliable?

A client who negotiates hard on your fees or hesitates when payment terms come up is telling you something important. Ask about their payment history with other service providers, and don't be afraid to request a deposit or set clear payment terms upfront. Chasing invoices costs your firm time and goodwill that could go toward paying clients.

Does their business match your firm's expertise?

Taking on a client whose industry, size or complexity sits outside your firm's usual work can mean a steep learning curve, and it's often the client who pays for that curve in slower turnaround times and avoidable mistakes.

Can your firm deliver long-term value?

A good client relationship should benefit both sides over time, not just cover this quarter's compliance work. Think about whether you can genuinely help this client grow (through advisory work, better systems or deeper insight into their numbers) or whether your client accounting services would simply be processing their transactions.

Why do you need to screen accounting clients?

Screening clients isn't just about avoiding difficult personalities. It protects five things that matter to the health of your firm:

• Profitability: Not every client is worth the time it takes to service them. A client who negotiates your fees down to the bone will eat into your margins long after the sales conversation ends.
• Capacity: Taking on more clients than your team can properly manage leads to rushed work and missed deadlines, even if each individual client seems manageable on paper.
• Compliance: In Singapore, ISCA's own professional standards require accounting firms to have a formal process for accepting and continuing client relationships, partly to manage the compliance and money-laundering risk that comes with taking on the wrong client.
• Client relationships: A client who's a poor fit rarely stays quiet about it, and a strained relationship can affect team morale and your firm's reputation with other clients and referral partners.
• Staff workload: The wrong client often creates disproportionate work for what they pay, pulling your team's time and attention away from clients who are a better fit.

What are the signs a client isn’t the right fit?

Some warning signs show up before you've even signed an engagement letter. Watch for:

• Unrealistic deadlines: A client who expects urgent turnaround on ongoing work may not understand or respect the time good accounting work takes.
• Poor record keeping: Shoeboxes of receipts and years of missing reconciliations aren't automatically a dealbreaker, but they should factor into your pricing and timeline.
• Price-only conversations: A client who only wants to talk about your fees, and never asks about your process, experience, or how you'll help them, is often looking for the cheapest option rather than the right fit.
• Reluctance to share information: Hesitation around providing financial documents, bank access or details about other advisors can be an early sign of bigger problems, or simply incompatibility with how your firm works.
• Previous disputes with accountants: It's worth asking why a prospective client is leaving their current accountant. A reasonable answer is a good sign; a pattern of blaming every past accountant is worth taking seriously.

What should go in a client resources folder?

Once you've learned more about the client, it's your turn to share more about your firm. Don't let them leave the meeting empty-handed: a simple resources folder—whether physical or emailed as links and attachments—gives them something concrete to reference and shows what working with your firm looks like.

• About us: Share your firm's vision, mission and purpose, so the client understands that this relationship means more to your team than just another job.
• Our team: Introduce the people the client might work with, with photos and short bios. This helps clients put a face to a name, and discourages them from only ever wanting to speak to one team member.
• Client rights and responsibilities: Set out clearly what the client can expect from you, and what you expect from them. Include it in their onboarding pack, keep it on your website, and reference it in your service agreement, so both sides are accountable from the start.
• The roadmap: Show the client a step-by-step timeline of what the next few months will look like. This removes uncertainty and gives you a natural opening to discuss deadlines or circumstances that might affect the plan.

What happens during the Discovery phase?

If the conversation has gone well, it's time to move into planning. This is often called the Discovery phase. A few things matter here:

• No changes are made to the client's books during this period. It’s purely research and review, which gives you a clear, informed starting point instead of a guess.
• Discovery is a valuable service in its own right. Price it properly and back it with a short Discovery Report.
• Schedule it for the month after your first meeting, priced around the client’s size and complexity.

Know when to walk away from a client

If you want a relationship you'll genuinely enjoy, lead with transparency instead, and try what's sometimes called the un-sell.

Start by asking yourself two honest questions: are they a good fit for you right now, and are you a good fit for them? If your gut says no, whether it's their communication style, their workload expectations or a mismatch with the software they use, there's no obligation to take them on. The reverse matters too: if your timeline, expertise or capacity genuinely isn't right for their needs, saying so and referring them elsewhere makes you the hero in that client's eyes, and in the eyes of whoever you refer them to.

Ask the client how they're feeling about the conversation, and encourage an honest answer. If it isn't a fit for them, it isn't a fit for you either, and letting go of the need to close removes pressure from both sides. Only once both of you are genuinely excited to move forward, with a clear understanding of price and scope, should you ask for a signed Discovery proposal. How a potential client responds when it's time to put money down tells you a lot, so where possible, get payment before starting work.

Follow up after a good client meeting

If both sides are genuinely on board, use that momentum. Get the proposal out the same day or the next, don't let the energy of a good conversation cool off. Follow it with a short email thanking the client, confirming the timeline in writing, and letting them know you need a signed proposal soon so you can hold the time for them in your calendar.

With practice, this entire process, from initial consultation to signed proposal, can happen in a single one-hour conversation. It saves your team time and headaches, and keeps your client list full of relationships you're genuinely glad to have. Once they’ve signed, your client onboarding checklist takes over from here. 

Grow your accounting practice with QuickBooks Online Accountant, a cloud-based accounting solution built to help accountants manage clients and their practice. Sign up to use QuickBooks Online Accountant for free.