Hello, Travis.
I appreciate you following the process using the QuickBooks article for accurate setup for your customers as CIS Contractors.
I recommend contacting our QuickBooks Live Support to investigate the unusual behavior of the specific box in your Settings. They can use their tools to identify the root cause and guide you on the next steps to take.
Here's how:
- Open your QuickBooks Online account.
- Head to the Help icon in the top right of your screen.
- In the Search bar, type Contact Us.
- Click the Contact Us option below.
- Choose Callback.
- Enter your Phone number, Full name, and Email address.
- Select Get a call.
To check our support availability hours, visit this resource: How to get help with QuickBooks.
Please let us know in the comments if there's anything else we can assist you with.