What counts as a reasonable vs unreasonable refusal?
In this section, we’ll outline three scenarios that will illustrate how the right to disconnect law is expected to apply in practice.
Scenario 1: Bookstore employee
Peter works at a bookstore in Sydney. One Saturday evening, he finishes his shift and heads home. An hour later, he gets a text from the bookstore owner saying that the shop security alarm has been activated because the front door was left unlocked.
Peter’s phone is on silent, and he doesn’t respond to his boss.
Right to Disconnect: Unreasonable.
Because securing the front door of the bookshop before he leaves is a part of Peter’s role, his refusal to respond to contact from his boss in this instance is unreasonable.
Scenario 2: Healthcare worker
Jane is a registered nurse who works at a hospital in Melbourne. On this day, she finished her shift at the usual time of 6:00 pm and went home. At 8:00 pm that evening, she received a group text from her supervisor, asking if someone can cover a shift the next day because another nurse is unwell.
Jane reads the text, but decides not to respond because she’s no longer on duty, and she has to attend university the next day.
Right to Disconnect: Reasonable
Jane’s response was reasonable, because the right to disconnect law means she doesn’t have to respond to messages sent outside of her work hours unless it’s an obligation of her employment, or an emergency.
Scenario 3: Operations supervisor
Amelia is an operations supervisor for a mid-sized manufacturing business. Her rostered hours are 8:00 am to 5:00 pm. At 7:00 pm, a team leader calls to report a machinery fault that occurred after hours. The fault could disrupt production the following morning and needs to be addressed.
Amelia sees the call but doesn’t answer, as she is preparing dinner for her family. She also believes the matter isn’t urgent enough to justify after-hours contact.
Right to Disconnect: Mediation Required
Because the issue involves workplace safety and operational risk, refusing to respond could be considered unreasonable. As an operations supervisor, Amelia has responsibilities that extend to equipment and safety compliance. However, she isn’t compensated for on-call duties and could argue her refusal was reasonable.
Her caring responsibilities at the time may also support her decision not to respond.