Hello there, @cwaterc.

Thank you for joining the thread and allow me to help print your W-2 successfully.

Have you tried following the steps provided above? 

If the same thing happens, you may save the form as a PDF and try printing the forms from there. We also offer a detailed guide on printing W-2 forms for your convenience. You  may check it here: Print W-2 forms.

Let me know how it goes by adding a comment below. I'm always here to help!