Like all things, not every aspect of pro forma is perfect. There are both benefits and downsides to the assumption structure that pro forma is built upon.
Benefits
Pro forma financial statements help owners identify growth opportunities and limit risk. Assume, for example, that a retailer creates a pro forma income statement for the upcoming year. The income statement includes these categories:
- Sales: How much product you sold
- Cost of goods sold: Direct material and labor costs incurred
- Gross profit: Sales minus cost of goods sold
- Operating expenses: Overhead costs
- Net income: Gross profit minus operating expenses
Each of the line items can be changed to create different scenarios. For example, sales might be presented as 15% higher (best case), 5% higher (expected), 20% lower (worst case). If material costs increase sharply, or there is a shortage of labor, the cost of sales will increase.
An owner can create pro forma financial statements and consider these questions:
- If I take on a new customer to increase sales by 15%, what is the cash flow impact if the customer pays in 30 days? What if the accounts receivable balance isn’t paid for 45 days?
- If I start buying materials from a new supplier, what is the impact on production if the supplier ships materials 20 days later than promised?
- To add a new product line that my customers want, I need to borrow from my line of credit. How much in total liabilities can I take on and still make the required principal and interest payments?
Pro forma financial statements are a great tool to evaluate alternatives. Most businesses have limited resources, and pro forma reports can help you make better decisions with what you have.
Limitations
Unfortunately, there are also disadvantages that accompany pro forma financial statements.
The limitation of these statements is that they show the business owner nothing more than a prediction. No matter how good or bad that portrayal may seem, it’s only a good guess as to what may happen.
These assumptions can be off by a little or a lot, but the bottom line is their outcomes should not be weighed too heavily in decision-making without other indicators to back up the assumption. And as we mentioned earlier, they are not in compliance with GAAP, which means they have to be labeled as pro forma and cannot replace formal financial statements.